Split, What Split?


In truth, we are all George Bailey.  In truth, we are all Mr. Potter.

I am speaking of the two opposing characters in the Frank Capra movie It’s a Wonderful Life.

After writing about that film in my December 20 post…

…a passage in the Robert A. Johnson book Owning Your Own Shadow brought me to this realization:

…the world is not divided into Baileys and Potters; rather, each one of us is divided into a Bailey and a Potter.

Johnson writes…

“The quickest way I know to break a person is to give him or her two sets of contradicting values—which is exactly what we do, in modern culture, with our Sunday and Monday moralities.

“We are taught by Christianity to follow a set of values that are almost entirely disregarded in everyday business life.”

Johnson then provides a list of those contradicting values.  Here’s an abbreviated version, with the practical value listed first and the opposing religious value, in italics, underneath: 

Practical Values —
            Religious Values




            Selling all & giving to the poor


            Obedience to authority


Sharp consciousness
            Meditative consciousness

Belief that more is better
            Belief that less is better

According to Johnson, these contradictions are built into our culture; thus we must deal with them, regardless of what our personal belief system may be.

So what is the result of living with such conflicts?  If we approach the situation wrongly, Johnson says…

“…we are bound in a neurotic paralysis in which we can do nothing.  Then we find that we are so anxious that we cannot even do that!  We cannot act or be still!  This is where many people stand and their suffering is intense…

“If we do something we enjoy, we spoil it with guilt about what we ought to be doing.  If we do what we ought, what we wish for and fantasize about spoils our discipline.”

So what’s the answer?  How do we heal the split?  How do we find peace?

Since Johnson started us down this path, I’ll let him take us the rest of the way:

“…I have pointed out the secular versus the religious attitude.  This is a flaming, vagrant error and is the seat of most neurotic suffering in humankind.

“To think that one way of action is profane and another sacred is to make terrible misuse of the language.

“There is no such thing as a religious act or list of characteristics.  There can only be religious insight that bridges or heals.  This is what restores and reconciles the opposites that have been torturing each of us.

“The religious faculty is the art of taking the opposites and binding them back together again, surmounting the split that has been causing so much suffering.”

So he tells us how without exactly telling us how.

But I believe that if we can begin to see every act, every moment as spiritual, we are on our way to healing the split, moving beyond opposition, and into, as Johnson writes, “the realm of paradox, where we are able to entertain simultaneously two contradictory notions and give them equal dignity.”

In other words, we resolve the contradiction by realizing there is no contradiction.

Here, I’m reminded of what Mark Twain said about smoking.  He claimed that quitting smoking was easy—he’d done it many times.

Many times, I’ve realized that there is no contradiction.  However, the problem keeps returning, because I keep forgetting.

But though I keep losing sight, though I keep finding myself back at square one…

…I believe that each time I come just a little closer to resolving the contradiction.

Yet I don’t expect the process to ever be complete.

So, I’m working to resolve a contradiction that will never be resolved.

That in itself would seem to be a contradiction.  Fortunately, through my hard work, I now see it as a paradox.

© 2010, Michael R. Patton
earnest audio


About Michael Patton

I am a poet, novelist, and fabulist...A new mythologist, a peace miller, a dream worker...I don't qualify as an illustrator or photographer--I just "make pictures"...I have thirteen books available at amazon... I currently reside in northwest Arkansas, but have lived and worked all over the United States... I'm self-taught, for the most part--which is like searching for the right door in the dark. It's an on-going process.... I don't want to write MY story, I want OUR story, so that's what I'm studying: the human story: past, present, future, in its many aspects--including the spiritual. I'm proceeding at a slow crawl.... I don't see the inner world and outer world as separate. By learning about myself, I learn about others, I learn about my world.... Conversely, as I struggle to understand what I see OUT THERE, I learn about myself.... But to be clear: I don't claim any special understanding. I'm still purblind, still only half-awake.... After frustrating experience with the publisher of my first novel, I've published on my own, beginning with e-books, with plans to move into print and audio. Even video.... Along with a second novel, I've now published eight books of poetry. Each poetry book focuses on a theme. For instance, the collection GLORIOUS TEDIOUS TRANSFORMATION is about the slow difficult wonderful process of change.... In that book, as with all my work, I try to be accessible to a general audience, while also striving to achieve a certain literary quality.
This entry was posted in artwork, myth, new age, psychology, religion, spirituality and tagged , , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s