In a Brown Study


Our mythologies and religions tell us who we are.

They tell us psychological truths.

With that in mind, should our new mythology include stories from psychological studies?  Don’t such studies ask us to consider the mysteries of the human psyche?

Consider what the story below tells us about ourselves:

In 1971, as part of a psychological experiment, researchers created a mock prison at Stanford University.

They randomly divided test subjects into two groups.  One group of twelve would be guards.  One group of twelve would be prisoners.

These twenty-four were selected from seventy-five applicants.  They were judged to be the most psychologically stable.

But problems quickly arose.  The fake prison became too much like a real prison.  A real prison with real problems.  The pseudo-guards begin acting in an authoritarian manner.  The pseudo-prisoners responded by acting like prisoners.  Except it wasn’t an act.  The psychic toil was real.

A prisoner suffered a mental breakdown after only 36 hours.  Another prisoner went on a hunger strike.  In one of the cell blocks, the prisoners revolted.

The guards became more and more abusive.  There was gamesmanship on both sides.

The mock prison, scheduled to last two weeks, was terminated after six days.

I heard of this experiment while still in high school.  The implications were obvious: we can easily become consumed by the roles we’re asked to play.

Unfortunately, I’ve too often forgotten this message in my adult life.  Though I’ve tried to be independent, to be self-aware…

…at times, I’ve lost myself—my better self—by becoming too involved in a particular “role”.

So what’s the use of such stories if our behavior isn’t changed for the better?

Well, maybe I needed to hear this story more than once.

When a story becomes part of a mythology, we receive its wisdom again and again, all through our lives.

It becomes a part of us.  It helps wake us up—if we let it, if we work with it.


…but aren’t we better served by stories of heroism?—stories that inspire us, that show us what we can be at our best?

The story of the Stanford experiment certainly doesn’t fit that category.  True, some prisoners did try to buck the system.  However, as far as I know, none stepped outside of his assigned role.  We have to wonder what these same prisoners might have done if given the role of guard.

No, it’s definitely not a story of heroism.  It’s a story that shows us at our worst, at our weakest.  Do we really need another such story?

Well, I think we can regain a sense of humility by having our weaknesses—our vulnerabilities—revealed.

 To do a better job of dealing with our worst instincts, we need to see them and feel some shame in seeing them.

Maybe then we can achieve a heroism that is not the false heroism of egotism, but the honest heroism of self-sacrifice.

Considered in this light, perhaps our new mythology could use the story of the mock prison.

It’s dramatic, but not a dramatization.  This scenario didn’t come from a writer.  This scenario came from us—all of us.  We have no choice but to accept its truth.

© 2011, Michael R. Patton
dreaming steps


About Michael Patton

I am a poet, novelist, and fabulist...A new mythologist, a peace miller, a dream worker...I don't qualify as an illustrator or photographer--I just "make pictures"...I have thirteen books available at amazon... I currently reside in northwest Arkansas, but have lived and worked all over the United States... I'm self-taught, for the most part--which is like searching for the right door in the dark. It's an on-going process.... I don't want to write MY story, I want OUR story, so that's what I'm studying: the human story: past, present, future, in its many aspects--including the spiritual. I'm proceeding at a slow crawl.... I don't see the inner world and outer world as separate. By learning about myself, I learn about others, I learn about my world.... Conversely, as I struggle to understand what I see OUT THERE, I learn about myself.... But to be clear: I don't claim any special understanding. I'm still purblind, still only half-awake.... After frustrating experience with the publisher of my first novel, I've published on my own, beginning with e-books, with plans to move into print and audio. Even video.... Along with a second novel, I've now published eight books of poetry. Each poetry book focuses on a theme. For instance, the collection GLORIOUS TEDIOUS TRANSFORMATION is about the slow difficult wonderful process of change.... In that book, as with all my work, I try to be accessible to a general audience, while also striving to achieve a certain literary quality.
This entry was posted in myth, new age, peace, photos, psychology, religion, spirituality and tagged , , , , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s